Menu
Log in

Log in
High Grade Expectations - FAQ Accordion

High Grade Expectations

“I have four teenagers with very different interests and abilities. I expect my two children who live with me to bring home report cards with no grade below a B. I used to ground them if grades slipped, but now I feel unsure about enforcing it strictly. How can I maintain expectations without damaging our relationship?”

— Concerned Parent

Dear Parent, here’s Positive Discipline guidance on maintaining high academic expectations while fostering teen autonomy:

Teens are transitioning from dependence to independence. Key points:

  • The prefrontal cortex, responsible for planning and decision-making, is still developing until ~25 years old.
  • Teens often assert identity by testing boundaries and differentiating from parents.
  • High expectations can be seen as control—how you communicate matters more than the expectation itself.

Shift your focus from control to influence:

  • Express that grades are their responsibility; you cannot make them succeed.
  • Ask curiosity questions without judgment: “What are your goals after high school?” “How do you feel about your grades?” “What could help you improve?”
  • Share your own fears respectfully: “I care about your future and I worry, but I know you’re capable.”
  • Maintain self-respect: don’t do their homework or intervene in ways that undermine their autonomy.

Even with autonomy, clear boundaries help teens thrive:

  • Identify “bottom lines” for safety and responsibility (e.g., driving rules, household agreements).
  • Communicate limits calmly and respectfully, and follow through consistently.
  • Focus on agreements, not grades alone; trust teens to manage their academics.
  • Recognize your teens’ strengths, skills, and resilience.
  • Allow mistakes—they are opportunities for learning and growth.
  • Encourage self-reflection rather than coercion or punishment.
  • Invest in positive interactions: shared meals, fun activities, brief quality time.


The Positive Discipline Association recieves a 5% donation for all purchases made at www.positivediscipline.com

© Positive Discipline Association
Terms and Conditions
Privacy and Cookies Policy

PO Box 888244, Atlanta, GA 30356 |  Toll-Free: 1-866-767-3472
Fax: 1-855-415-2477 | E-mail: info@positivediscipline.org
Contact Us 
Cancellation Policy